The portrait of Sarah Collins was found in the Collins family album. Sarah's older brother, Barnabas, would look at it whenever he was trying to figure out why Sarah's ghost would not appear to him. Dr Julia Hoffman, pretending to be a historian, found the portrait and showed it to young David Collins, who had neither seen the portrait nor heard of Sarah before. The portrait was painted by an unknown artist.

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.