The Enemy Within 
The Lucifer Gambit 
Matthew talks to Amy as she leaves Collinsport for Saratoga Springs. He admires a pendant given to her by Professor Stokes and seems to be romantically interested in her. While returning to Collinsport, Matthew tells her about the arrival of Tom Lacey and the Beyond The Grave television crew. This surprises Amy and Matthew says it surprised another passenger as well. He points her in the direction of the other passenger who, co-incidentally, is her sister-in-law Sabrina - a woman she hasn't seen since the death of her brother, Chris.
Carriage of the Damned 
Sabrina once again finds herself meeting Matthew when she boards his train searching for the missing head of Gerard Stiles. Matthew proves himself to be brave in assisting Sabrina and Hallie. Despite being scared, he's calm under pressure. He briefly meets Amy again but, before he can really talk to her, she leaves Collinsport after discovering the truth about her brother's death.
Background information and notes 
- Matthew was played by Barra Collins.